148 views
I have a  question to ask.
I just wanted to know, if a person is doing fard salah and by mistake he reads  the same surah after surah fatiha in both the rakats what is the ruling here Should he do  sajde sahw or repeat the salah?
umme nabeel usa
asked Dec 6, 2021 in Prayer / Friday & Eidain prayers by Rahimuddin

1 Answer

Ref. No. 1723/43-1410

In the name of Allah the most Grcious the most Merciful

The answer to your question is as follows:

One should not recite the same Surah in both rak'ats in Fard namaz (obligatory prayers). The jurists have considered it disliked (Makrooh Tanzihi). However, there is no problem if this happens by mistake. In any case, there is no need to do sajdae sahw or to repeat the prayer. However, in Nawafil (optional prayers) it is permissible to recite the same surahs in both rak'ahs.

لا بأس أن يقرأ سورةً ويعيدها في الثانية. (قوله: لا بأس أن يقرأ سورةً إلخ ) أفاد أنه يكره تنزيها، وعليه يحمل جزم القنية بالكراهة، ويحمل فعله عليه الصلاة والسلام لذلك على بيان الجواز، هذا إذا لم يضطر، فإن اضطر بأن قرأ في الأولى: {قل أعوذ برب الناس} الناس أعادها في الثانية إن لم يختم، نهر (الدر المختار مع شرحه ردالمحتار (الشامي) (1 / 546)

And Allah knows best

Darul Ifta

Darul Uloom Waqf Deoband

answered Dec 9, 2021 by Darul Ifta
...